May 20, 2012

TCHC Audit Reveals Massive Spending Issues

According to a report by the Toronto Star, the Toronto Community Housing Corporation could use a little work with their “lavish spending” tactics.

The Star cites an unnamed source in their report and says that the auditor general’s report will reveal more about the TCHC’s spending soon enough.

“Here, according to our source, is a partial list of what seem to be highly inappropriate expenses: $1,850 for a boat cruise for the purposes of staff development; $1,925 for manicures and pedicures; $6,000 for a planning session in Muskoka; $40,000 for a staff Christmas party in 2009; $53,500 for a similar bash in 2008; $800 for four massage practitioners at a staff picnic,” writes Joe Fiorito.

The money for the luxuries, says the report, comes from the rent paid by tenants. And with the state of affairs at many of Toronto’s community housing sites less than luxurious, it can sting a little to hear that the TCHC is spending $40,000 on the staff Christmas party.

The report will be delivered to TCHC board members over the weekend and should be out for public perusal by Monday, so we’ll all get to have a crack at it then. It’s been bumped up for unknown reasons, as the report’s original release date was late March.

Fiorito and the Star claim to have seen an internal document that reveals the TCHC report will assert that “the financial amounts raised in the Auditor-General’s report are well below the materiality thresholds for TCHC.”

Fiorito rightly worries that the Ford administration in Toronto will see this as an opportunity to strip the TCHC and, as a result, save millions of dollars in the process. With the budget issues we’ve been discussing here lately, that seems a likely avenue to take. The solution is likely to aim in the direction of private enterprise, of course.

In the end, it’s hard to predict how this will play out. But it can’t be good if the Star and its source have any insight at all.

Ford Budget Passes Amid Criticism

Mayor Rob Ford’s budget may have passed on Thursday afternoon, but that hasn’t stopped his critics from sounding off.

As we talked about a couple of days ago, veteran centrist councillor Raymond Cho demonstrated his concerns over Ford’s tactics. With the budget having cleared, others are suggesting, too, that it means short-term gain but “long-term pain” for Toronto residents.

“I think we’re looking at much bigger cuts (in 2012). This year we’ve affected what the budget committee called ‘a few citizens.’ We’re talking about thousands and thousands and thousands being affected next time around,” said former budget chief Shelley Carroll.

There is, as we reported in the past, a $774 million deficit projected for 2012. That will mean that deep, significant cuts will need to be made to a host of programs if there is to be any salvaging of the conditions in Toronto. With Ford’s $9.4 billion budget approved Thursday, it included no property tax increase. That’s the first time the city of Toronto has seen no increase in that department in over a decade.

Among the programs scrapped were the downspout program and funding for the Toronto Public Library’s urban affairs branch. The TTC will also reduce some of its services and fees will go up.

On top of that, there’s pressure because the city’s surplus was used up to balance the 2011 budget. That compounds the impending deficit considerably and makes it more of a problem.

Ford, for his part, has kept quiet about how he intends to meet the 2012 issues. For now, it appears that he’s focused in gaining ground from the 2011 budget and has little concern for looking ahead. “The ink’s not even dry on the 2011 budget,” he said, “so I want people to enjoy the zero per cent tax increase.”

Former TTC Chairman Accused of Overspending

Former TTC chairman Adam Giambrone apparently went over his $125,000 budget in 2010 and will now be asked to repay about $3,500.

The news comes according to the new chair of the TTC Karen Stintz (Ward 16 — Eglinton-Lawrence).  TTC chief general manager Gary Webster outlined what was about $3,344.92 in overspending in a memo sent to the commissioners and Stintz asserted that those who go over the budget are responsible for overages.

Giambrone stepped down from his post last November and was replaced by Stintz. Details of the overspending on Giambrone’s account are due to be brought before the TTC in a March meeting.

It was Ward 34 councillor Denzil Minnan-Wong who requested the breakdown on Giambrone. He also prompted the sending of the memo, reports say, but he wasn’t available for comment at press time.

For many, news of Giambrone’s overspending comes as no surprise. It was last November that he took French lessons on the public tab – after he quit municipal politics. Two bills from the Alliance Française school revealed expenditures for $2,299.50, and $2,299.50. He even had a short-lived campaign for mayor that ran out of steam in February.

The criticism over the French lessons at the time came because Giambrone knew he was no longer going to be serving the public good. His logic was that he represented the city of Toronto to many French municipalities, but with the politics job ending the lessons seemed a little funny to many political watchdogs.

With that in mind, it’s encouraging that the TTC is looking in the right direction with this overspending.

It should also be noted that the TTC budget does not include travel. It’s hard to say just where Giambrone’s overspending took place in line with what’s allowed in the budget, too.